“….but it takes good scholarship to create one.”
This title is taken from an editorial in Molecular Biology in the Cell which basically admonishes poor refereeing techniques and lays out how these should be done and how both editors and authors should deal with them. It’s all very, very good stuff, I just hope people pay attention to it. If only more people or journals went with this kind of thing.
It’s always nice when you shout about various things quite loudly (like this, this and this) and then see that quite independently in a rather branch of study the same problems are being felt and the similar solutions proposed.
Thanks to Graeme Lloyd for putting me onto it.